/Users/andrea/_magisterarbeit/korpus/clean/testkorpus/34/file10.html NN ----------------------------------------- : An DT Open JJ Letter NN to TO Google NP Regarding VVG Its PP$ Proposed VVN Gmail NP Service NP From IN . SENT World NN Privacy NN Forum NP Privacy NN Rights NP Clearinghouse NN and CC Australian JJ Privacy NN Foundation NP Grayson NP Barber NP , , Privacy NN Advocate NN Bits NNS of IN Freedom NP Netherlands NPS British NP Columbia NP Civil NP Liberties NPS Association NP Canada NP Calegislation NP CASPIAN NP Consumers NNS Against IN Supermarket NN Privacy NN Invasion NN and CC Numbering VVG Roger NP Clarke NP , , Privacy NN Research NN and CC Advocate NN Australia NP Consumer NP Action NP Consumer NP Federation NP of IN America NP Consumer NP Federation NP of IN California NP Consumer NP Task NP Force NP for IN Automotive NP Issues NPS Electronic NP Privacy NN Information NP Center NP Federaci NP n NN de NP Consumidores NP en IN Acci NP n NN FACUA NP Spain NP Foundation NP for IN Information NP Policy NP Research NP United NP Kingdom NP Mari NP Frank NP , , Esq NN . SENT , , Author NN of IN Identity NN Theft NN Survival NN Kit NP Simson NP L NP . SENT Garfinkel NP , , Author NN of IN Database NN Nation NP Edward NP Hasbrouck NP , , Author NN and CC Consumer NN Advocate NN Massachusetts NP Consumer NP Assistance NP Council NP Massachusetts NP Consumers NPS Coalition NP National NP Association NP of IN Consumer NP Agency NP Administrators NPS NACAA NP National NP Consumers NPS League NP PrivacyActivism NN Privacy NN International NP United NP Kingdom NP Privacy NN Rights NNS Now RB Coalition NP Privacy NN Times NP Private NP Citizen NP , , Inc NP . SENT Privaterra NP Canada NP Public NP Information NP Research NP , , Inc NP . SENT Utility NP Consumers NPS Action NP Network NP April NP 6 CD , , 2004 CD Sergey NP Brin NP , , Co NP Founder NN President NP , , Technology NP Larry NP Page NP , , Co NP Founder NN President NP , , Products NP Google NP Inc NP . SENT 1600 CD Amphitheatre NN Parkway NP Mountain NP View NP , , CA MD 94043 CD Dear NP Mr NP . SENT Brin NP and CC Mr NP . SENT Page NN . SENT Google NP s PP proposed VVN Gmail NP service NN and CC the DT practices NNS and CC policies NNS of IN its PP$ business NN units NNS raise VVP significant JJ and CC troubling JJ questions NNS . SENT First RB , , Google NP has VHZ proposed VVN scanning VVG the DT text NN of IN all DT incoming JJ emails NNS for IN ad NN placement NN . SENT The DT scanning VVG of IN confidential JJ email NP violates VVZ the DT implicit JJ trust NN of IN an DT email NP service NN provider NN . SENT Further RBR , , the DT unlimited JJ period NN for IN data NN retention NN poses VVZ unnecessary JJ risks NNS of IN misuse NN . SENT Second RB , , Google's NP overall JJ data NN retention NN and CC correlation NN policies NNS are VBP problematic JJ in IN their PP$ lack NN of IN clarity NN and CC broad JJ scope NN . SENT Google NP has VHZ not RB set VVN specific JJ , , finite JJ limits NNS on IN how WRB long JJ it PP will MD retain VV user NN account NN , , email NP , , and CC transactional JJ data NNS . SENT And CC Google NP has VHZ not RB set VVN clear JJ written JJ policies NNS about IN its PP$ data NNS sharing VVG between IN business NN units NNS . SENT Third JJ , , the DT Gmail NP system NN sets VVZ potentially RB dangerous JJ precedents NNS and CC establishes VVZ reduced JJ expectations NNS of IN privacy NN in IN email NP communications NNS . SENT These DT precedents NNS may MD be VB adopted VVN by IN other JJ companies NNS and CC governments NNS and CC may MD persist VV long RB after IN Google NP is VBZ gone VVN . SENT We PP urge VVP you PP to TO suspend VV the DT Gmail NP service NN until IN the DT privacy NN issues NNS are VBP adequately RB addressed VVN . SENT Email NP Scanning VVG in IN Google NP s PP Proposed VVD Gmail NP Service NP The DT email NP text NN scanning VVG infrastructure NN that IN Google NP has VHZ built VVN is VBZ powerful JJ and CC global JJ in IN reach NN . SENT Google NP has VHZ not RB created VVN written JJ policies NNS to TO date VV that IN adequately RB protect VV consumers NNS from IN the DT unintended JJ consequences NNS of IN building VVG this DT structure NN . SENT It PP is VBZ , , in IN fact NN , , arguable JJ that IN no DT policy NN could MD adequately RB protect VV consumers NNS from IN future JJ abuses NNS . SENT The DT societal JJ consequences NNS of IN initiating VVG a DT global JJ infrastructure NN to TO continually RB monitor VV the DT communications NNS of IN individuals NNS are VBP significant JJ and CC far RB reaching VVG with IN immediate JJ and CC long JJ term NN privacy NN implications NNS . SENT Currently RB , , individuals NNS may MD have VH the DT understanding NN that IN Google NP s PP system NN is VBZ not RB that DT different JJ in IN nature NN from IN scanning VVG messages NNS for IN spam NN , , which WDT is VBZ a DT common JJ practice NN today NN . SENT There EX is VBZ a DT fundamental JJ difference NN , , however RB . SENT With IN Gmail NP , , individuals NNS incoming JJ emails NNS will MD be VB scanned VVN and CC seeded VVN with IN ads NNS . SENT This DT will MD happen VV every DT time NN Gmail NN subscribers NNS open VVP their PP$ emails NNS to TO re NN read VV them PP , , no DT matter NN how WRB long JJ they PP have VHP been VBN stored VVN . SENT Inserting VVG new JJ content NN from IN third JJ party NN advertisers NNS in IN incoming JJ emails NNS is VBZ fundamentally RB different JJ than IN removing VVG harmful JJ viruses NNS and CC unwanted JJ spam NN . SENT Another DT potential JJ misconception NN about IN the DT Gmail NP system NN is VBZ that IN the DT scanning VVG will MD take VV place NN in IN isolation NN . SENT The DT email NP is VBZ scanned VVN , , and CC ad NN text NN is VBZ delivered VVN . SENT But CC that DT is VBZ not RB the DT end NN of IN the DT story NN . SENT The DT delivery NN of IN the DT ad NN text NN based VVN on IN emails NNS is VBZ a DT continual JJ on IN the DT fly NN stream NN . SENT This DT technology NN requires VVZ a DT substantial JJ supply NN chain NN of IN directory NN structures NNS , , databases NNS , , logs NNS , , and CC a DT long JJ memory NN . SENT Auditing VVG trails NNS of IN the DT ad NN text NN are VBP kept VVN , , and CC the DT data NNS could MD be VB correlated VVN with IN the DT data NNS Google NP collects VVZ via IN its PP$ other JJ business NN units NNS such JJ as IN its PP$ search NN site NN and CC its PP$ networking NN site NN , , Orkut NP . SENT Google NP has VHZ countered VVN criticism NN of IN Gmail NP by IN highlighting VVG that IN a DT computer NN , , not RB a DT human JJ , , will MD scan VV the DT content NN of IN the DT e NN mail NN , , thereby RB making VVG the DT system NN less RBR invasive JJ . SENT We PP think VVP a DT computer NN system NN , , with IN its PP$ greater JJR storage NN , , memory NN , , and CC associative JJ ability NN than IN a DT human NN s PP , , could MD be VB just RB as RB invasive JJ as IN a DT human JJ listening NN to TO the DT communications NNS , , if IN not RB more RBR so RB . SENT That IN the DT Gmail NP scanning VVG and CC monitoring NN is VBZ being VBG used VVN for IN advertising NN right NN now RB is VBZ distracting VVG , , because IN it PP is VBZ a DT transient JJ use NN . SENT Scanning VVG personal JJ communications NNS in IN the DT way NN Google NP is VBZ proposing VVG is VBZ letting VVG the DT proverbial JJ genie NN out IN of IN the DT bottle NN . SENT Today NN , , Google NP wants VVZ to TO make VV a DT profit NN from IN selling VVG ads NNS . SENT But CC tomorrow NN , , another DT company NN may MD have VH completely RB different JJ ideas NNS about IN how WRB to TO use VV such PDT an DT infrastructure NN and CC the DT data NNS it PP captures VVZ . SENT Google NN could MD tomorrow NN by IN choice NN or CC by IN court NN order NN , , employ VVP its PP$ scanning VVG system NN for IN law NN enforcement NN purposes NNS . SENT We PP note VVP that IN in IN one CD recent JJ case NN , , the DT Federal NP Bureau NP of IN Investigation NP obtained VVD a DT court NN order NN compelling JJ an DT automobile NN navigation NN service NN to TO convert VV its PP$ system NN into IN a DT tool NN for IN monitoring VVG in IN car NN conversations NNS . SENT How WRB long RB will MD it PP be VB until IN law NN enforcement NN compels VVZ Google NP into IN a DT similar JJ situation NN . SENT Google NP has VHZ been VBN quick JJ to TO state NN that IN it PP does VVZ not RB intend VV to TO correlate VV or CC share VV consumer NN data NNS between IN its PP$ business NN units NNS . SENT But CC unless IN Google NP puts VVZ a DT consumer NN promise NN into IN its PP$ privacy NN policy NN that WDT states VVZ it PP will MD never RB correlate VV the DT data NNS , , then RB Google NP is VBZ not RB putting VVG its PP$ money NN where WRB its PP$ mouth NN is VBZ . SENT In IN a DT nation NN of IN laws NNS , , Google NP needs VVZ to TO make VV its PP$ promises NNS in IN writing NN . SENT Gmail VV s PP Potential JJ Conflict NN with IN International NP Law NP The DT Gmail NP system NN may MD conflict NN with IN Europe NP s PP privacy NN laws NNS , , specifically RB , , Directive NN 95 CD 46 CD EC NP , , also RB called VVD the DT EU NP Privacy NN Directive NN . SENT This DT directive NN states NNS , , among IN other JJ things NNS , , that DT users NNS consent NN must MD be VB informed VVN , , specific JJ , , and CC unambiguous JJ pursuant JJ to TO Article NP 7 CD a DT of IN Dir NP . SENT 95 CD 46 CD EC NP . SENT As IN it PP has VHZ been VBN proposed VVN , , and CC based VVN on IN the DT current JJ Gmail NP privacy NN policy NN , , the DT consent NN of IN EU NP based VVN Gmail NP users NNS cannot NN necessarily RB be VB considered VVN informed JJ , , specific JJ , , and CC unambiguous JJ in IN regards VVZ to TO the DT scanning VVG , , storage NN and CC further JJR processing NN of IN their PP$ e NN mails NNS . SENT The DT need NN for IN informed JJ , , specific JJ , , and CC unambiguous JJ consent NN also RB applies VVZ to TO the DT potential NN linking VVG of IN EU NP citizens NNS e SYM mails VVZ to TO their PP$ search NN histories NNS . SENT Additional JJ issues NNS with IN data NN retention NN may MD also RB exist VV under IN the DT EU NP Privacy NN Directive NN . SENT The DT Dangers NNS of IN Lowered VVN Privacy NN Expectations NNS in IN the DT Email NP Medium NN Ultimately RB , , however RB , , this DT discussion NN is VBZ not RB solely RB about IN Google NP . SENT It PP is VBZ about RB the DT global JJ tools NNS Google NP is VBZ building VVG , , and CC the DT ways NNS these DT tools NNS and CC systems NNS stand VVP to TO alter VV how WRB individuals NNS perceive VVP the DT sanctity NN of IN private JJ communications NNS in IN the DT electronic JJ sphere NN . SENT These DT perceptions NNS and CC standards NNS may MD persist VV long RB after IN Google NP as IN a DT company NN is VBZ gone VVN . SENT Google NP needs VVZ to TO realize VV that DT many JJ different JJ companies NNS and CC even RB governments NNS can MD and CC likely RB will MD walk VV through IN the DT email NP scanning VVG door NN once IN it PP is VBZ opened VVN . SENT As IN people NNS become VVP accustomed VVN to TO the DT notion NN that IN email NP scanning VVG for IN ad NN delivery NN is VBZ acceptable JJ , , mission NN creep VV is VBZ a DT real JJ possibility NN . SENT Other JJ companies NNS and CC governments NNS may MD have VH very RB different JJ ideas NNS about IN data NN correlation NN than IN Google NP does VVZ , , and CC may MD have VH different JJ motivations NNS for IN scanning VVG the DT body NN of IN email NP messages NNS . SENT Google NP itself PP , , in IN the DT absence NN of IN clear JJ written JJ promises NNS and CC policies NNS , , may MD experience VV a DT change NN of IN course NN and CC choose VV to TO profit VV from IN its PP$ large JJ stores NNS of IN consumer NN data NNS culled VVN from IN private JJ communications NNS . SENT The DT lowered VVN expectations NNS of IN email NP privacy NN that IN Google's NP system NN has VHZ the DT potential NN to TO create VV is VBZ no DT small JJ matter NN . SENT Once RB an DT information NN architecture NN is VBZ built VVN , , it PP functions NNS much RB like IN a DT building NN that IN building NN may MD be VB used VVN by IN many JJ different JJ owners NNS , , and CC its PP$ blueprints NNS may MD be VB replicated VVN in IN many JJ other JJ places NNS . SENT Google's NP technology NN is VBZ proprietary JJ , , but CC the DT precedents NNS it PP sets VVZ are VBP not RB . SENT Conclusion NN We PP request VVP the DT following NN of IN Google NP . SENT 1 LS . SENT First RB , , Google NP must MD suspend VV its PP$ implementation NN of IN scanning VVG the DT full JJ text NN of IN emails NNS for IN determining VVG ad NN placement NN . SENT 2 LS . SENT Second RB , , Google NP must MD clarify VV its PP$ information NN retention NN and CC data NN correlation NN policy NN amongst IN its PP$ business NN units NNS , , partners NNS , , and CC affiliates NNS . SENT This DT means VVZ that IN Google NP must MD set VV clear JJ data NNS retention NN and CC deletion NN dates NNS and CC establish VV detailed JJ written JJ policies NNS about IN data NNS sharing VVG and CC correlation NN amongst IN its PP$ business NN units NNS and CC partners NNS . SENT Respectfully RB submitted VVN and CC signed VVN , , Pam NP Dixon NP , , Executive NP Director NP World NP Privacy NN Forum NP Beth NP Givens NP , , Director NP Privacy NN Rights NP Clearinghouse NN and CC the DT following VVG individuals NNS and CC organizations NNS . SENT John NP Corker NP , , Chair NN Australian JJ Privacy NN Foundation NP Grayson NP Barber NP Privacy NN Advocate NN Maurice NP Wessling NP Bits NNS of IN Freedom NP Netherlands NPS Murray NP Mollard NP , , Executive NP Director NP British NP Columbia NP Civil NP Liberties NPS Association NP Canada NP Dian NP Black NP , , Executive NP Director NP Calegislation NP Katherine NP Albrecht NP , , Ed NP . SENT M NN . SENT , , Founder NN and CC Director NP CASPIAN NP Consumers NNS Against IN Supermarket NN Privacy NN Invasion NN and CC Numbering VVG Roger NP Clarke NP Australia NP Privacy NN Researcher NN , , Advocate NN and CC eBusiness NN Consultant NN Ken NP McEldowney NP , , Executive NP Director NP Consumer NP Action NP Jean NP Ann NP Fox NP , , Director NP of IN Consumer NP Protection NP Consumer NP Federation NP of IN America NP Richard NP Holober NP , , Director NP Consumer NP Federation NP of IN California NP Will NP deHoo NP , , Director NP Consumer NP Task NP Force NP For IN Automotive NP Issues NPS Chris NP Hoofnagle NP , , Associate NP Director NP Electronic NP Privacy NN Information NP Center NP Francisco NP Sanchez NP Legr NP n NN , , President NP of IN FACUA NP , , Federaci NP n NN de NP Consumidores NP en IN Acci NP n NN FACUA NP Spain NP Ian NP Brown NP Foundation NP for IN Information NP Policy NP Research NP United NP Kingdom NP Mari NP Frank NP , , Esq NN . SENT Author NN of IN the DT Identity NN Theft NN Survival NN Kit NP Simson NP L NP . SENT Garfinkel NP MIT NP Computer NP Science NP and CC Artificial JJ Intelligence NP Laboratory NP Author NN , , Database NN Nation NN . SENT The DT Death NN of IN Privacy NN in IN the DT 21 CD st NP Century NP Edward NP Hasbrouck NP Author NN and CC Consumer NN Advocate NN Paul NP Schrader NP , , Executive NP Director NP Massachusetts NP Consumer NP Assistance NP Council NP Paul NP J NP . SENT Schlaver NP , , Chair NN Massachusetts NP Consumers NP Coalition NP Kathleen NP Thuner NP , , President NP National NP Association NP of IN Consumer NP Agency NP Administrators NPS NACAA NP Linda NP Golodner NP , , President NP National NP Consumers NPS League NP Deborah NP Pierce NP , , Executive NP Director NP PrivacyActivism NP Simon NP Davies NP Privacy NN International NP United NP Kingdom NP Remar NP Sutton NP , , Co NP Founder NN Privacy NN Rights NNS Now RB Coalition NP Evan NP Hendricks NP Privacy NN Times NP Robert NP Bulmash NP , , President NP Private NP Citizen NP , , Inc NP . SENT Robert NP Guerra NP , , Managing NP Director NP Privaterra NP project NN of IN Computer NP Professionals NNS for IN Social NP Responsibility NN Canada NP Daniel NP Brandt NP , , President NP Public NP Information NP Research NP , , Inc NP . SENT Michael NP Shames NP , , Executive NP Director NP Utility NP Consumers NPS Action NP Network NP