/Users/andrea/_magisterarbeit/korpus/clean/trainkorpus/23/file11.html NN ----------------------------------------- : Advertise VVP Subscribe VV Donate NP Search NP Login NP A NP New NP New NP Low NP T NN P NN They PP couldn NN t NN possibly RB believe VVP that IN a DT wrongfully RB convicted VVN capital NN defendant NN should MD be VB denied VVN a DT federal JJ court NN review NN of IN evidence NN . SENT Well RB By IN Alan NP Berlow NP Red NP Parallels VVZ T NN P NN Haynes NP Johnson NP s PP new JJ McCarthy NP book NN doesn NN t NN break VV much JJ ground NN . SENT By IN David NP Greenberg NP The DT New NP Nativism NN T NN P NN The DT alarming JJ overlap VVP between IN white JJ nationalists NNS and CC mainstream JJ anti JJ immigrant NN forces NNS . SENT By IN Leonard NP Zeskind NP How WRB They PP Did VVD It PP T NN P NN Through IN manipulation NN and CC unaccountability NN , , basically RB . SENT By IN Matthew NP Yglesias NP Table NN of IN Contents NNS Pray NP and CC Tell VV Jack NP Cloonan NP has VHZ done VVN his PP$ share NN of IN terrorism NN interrogations NNS . SENT Instead RB of IN torture VV , , he PP recommends VVZ prayer NN rugs NNS and CC figs NNS . SENT Yes UH , , figs NNS . SENT By IN Jason NP Vest NP Issue NN Date NN . SENT 07 CD . SENT 03 CD . SENT 05 CD Print NP Friendly NP Email NP Article NP On IN May NP 13 CD , , 2004 CD , , as IN the DT world NN media NNS were VBD in IN full JJ scrum NN over IN Abu NP Ghraib NP , , an DT FBI NP agent NN who WP had VHD spent VVN time NN interviewing VVG terrorism NN suspects NNS at IN the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT detention NN facility NN at IN Guantanamo NP Bay NP , , Cuba NP , , red JJ off IN a DT gloomy JJ e NN mail NN to TO a DT colleague NN . SENT Venting VVG about IN what WP had VHD happened VVN in IN Iraq NP and CC expressing VVG his PP$ fears NNS that IN , , despite IN the DT scandal NN s PP coverage NN , , nothing NN would MD change VV , , much RB of IN the DT agent NN s PP angst NN had VHD to TO do VV with IN post NN September NP 11 CD notions NNS that IN treating VVG terrorism NN suspects NNS as IN human JJ beings NNS was VBD neither RB necessary JJ nor CC useful JJ . SENT From IN what WP CNN NP reports NNS , , General NP Janis NP Karpinski NP at IN Abu NP Ghraib NP said VVD that IN General NP Geoffrey NP Miller NP came VVD to TO the DT prison NN several JJ months NNS ago RB and CC told VVD her PP they PP wanted VVD to TO gitmoize VV Abu NP Ghraib NP , , he PP wrote VVD . SENT If IN this DT refers VVZ to TO intelligence NN gathering NN as IN I PP suspect VVP , , it PP suggests VVZ that IN he PP has VHZ continued VVN to TO support VV interrogation NN strategies NNS we PP not RB only RB advised VVN against IN , , but CC questioned VVD in IN terms NNS of IN effectiveness NN we PP were VBD surprised VVN to TO read VV an DT article NN in IN Stars NP and CC Stripes NNS , , in IN which WDT General NP Miller NP is VBZ quoted VVN as IN saying VVG that IN he PP believes VVZ in IN the DT rapport NN building NN approach NN . SENT This DT is VBZ not RB what WP he PP was VBD saying VVG at IN Guantanamo NP Bay NP when WRB I PP was VBD there RB . SENT One CD among IN tens NNS of IN thousands NNS of IN of IN cial JJS documents NNS pried VVD out RP of IN government NN hands NNS under IN the DT Freedom NP of IN Information NP Act NP thanks NNS to TO the DT American NP Civil NP Liberties NPS Union NP , , this DT one NN , , like IN so RB many JJ others NNS , , never RB found VVD its PP$ way NN into IN anyone NN s PP story NN . SENT But CC from IN a DT review NN of IN thousands NNS of IN documents NNS e NN mails NNS , , still RB unreported JJ communiqu NN s PP , , and CC other JJ pieces NNS of IN paper NN certain JJ themes NNS have VHP become VVN increasingly RB apparent JJ . SENT Among IN the DT most RBS consistent JJ . SENT FBI NP agents NNS issued VVD repeated JJ objections NNS to TO the DT use NN of IN torture VV against IN foreign JJ terrorism NN suspects NNS . SENT And CC from IN this DT theme NN emerges VVZ a DT conclusion NN that IN future JJ presidential JJ administrations NNS , , and CC all DT American JJ citizens NNS , , would MD do VV well RB to TO remember VV . SENT For IN the DT purpose NN of IN prying VVG actionable JJ information NN from IN suspects NNS , , torture VVP is VBZ essentially RB useless JJ . SENT As IN T NN . SENT J NP . SENT Harrington NP , , a DT senior JJ FBI NP counterterrorism NN of IN cial NNS , , simply RB states NNS in IN one CD memo NN , , the DT FBI NP has VHZ been VBN successful JJ for IN many JJ years NNS obtaining VVG confessions NNS via IN non JJ confrontational JJ interviewing VVG techniques NNS . SENT as IN an DT e NN mail NN from IN an DT unnamed JJ FBI NP agent NN concludes VVZ , , the DT speci NN c SYM guidance NN FBI NP agents NNS continue VVP to TO give VV is VBZ to TO follow VV FBI NP policy NN just RB as IN you PP would MD in IN your PP$ eld NN of IN ce NNS . SENT Utilize VV our PP$ methods NNS that WDT are VBP proven VVN . SENT Last JJ year NN , , I PP increasingly RB wanted VVD the DT insight NN of IN someone NN who WP had VHD successfully RB interrogated VVN terrorism NN suspects NNS without IN resorting VVG to TO violent JJ or CC demeaning VVG practices NNS . SENT Several JJ people NNS told VVD me PP about IN a DT veteran JJ FBI NP agent NN , , recently RB retired VVN from IN the DT New NP York NP eld NN of IN ce NNS , , who WP was VBD so RB opposed VVN to TO the DT United NP States NPS burgeoning VVG renditions NNS and CC torture VV regime NN that IN his PP$ pointed JJ questions NNS on IN the DT subject NN to TO FBI NP Director NP Robert NP Mueller NP in IN a DT 2002 CD meeting NN had VHD drawn VVN Mueller NP s PP lasting VVG ire NN . SENT This DT , , I PP thought VVD , , was VBD the DT man NN to TO see VV . SENT When WRB I NP nally NP met VVD Jack NP Cloonan NP on IN a DT violent JJ and CC aberrantly RB wintry JJ spring NN night NN at IN the DT City NP Hall NP Restaurant NP in IN lower JJR Manhattan NP s PP Tribeca NP earlier RBR this DT year NN , , I PP asked VVD him PP if IN he PP was VBD surprised VVN by IN the DT refusal NN of IN most JJS FBI NP agents NNS to TO endorse VV or CC embrace VV the DT new JJ rules NNS of IN interrogation NN . SENT He PP said VVD he PP wasn NN t NN . SENT FBI NP agents NNS , , as RB of IN cers NNS of IN the DT court NN , , know VV what WP the DT rules NNS are VBP , , he PP said VVD with IN quiet JJ conviction NN as IN the DT storm NN raged VVD outside JJ . SENT We PP have VHP procedures NNS to TO follow VV . SENT We PP rmly RB believe VVP in IN this DT thing NN called VVD due JJ process NN , , and CC do VVP not RB see VV it PP as IN something NN pass NN or CC something NN that WDT should MD be VB seen VVN as IN an DT impediment NN . SENT When WRB I PP went VVD to TO see VV him PP a DT couple NN of IN months NNS later RBR at IN his PP$ family NN s PP suburban JJ New NP Jersey NP home NN , , at IN a DT moment NN when WRB the DT ow NN of IN daily JJ stories NNS revealing VVG new JJ instances NNS of IN torture VVP had VHD run VVN dry JJ , , he PP said VVD that IN as RB appalling JJ as IN the DT stories NNS were VBD , , he PP was VBD at IN least JJS proud JJ that IN documents NNS were VBD validating VVG the DT FBI NP approach NN to TO interrogation NN , , even RB if IN the DT administration NN wasn NN t NN interested JJ . SENT A DT soft JJ spoken VVN , , mustached JJ man NN in IN sweater NN and CC slacks NNS with IN an DT air NN of IN tranquility NN and CC a DT taste NN for IN alt JJ country NN music NN , , Cloonan NP who WP retired VVD from IN the DT bureau NN s PP New NP York NP eld NN of IN ce JJR after IN 32 CD years NNS in IN 2002 CD , , and CC is VBZ now RB a DT sometimes RB analyst NN for IN ABC NP News NP has VHZ had VHN a DT career NN that IN s PP about IN 10 CD percent NN The DT Sopranos NNS and CC 90 CD percent NN Fredrick NP Forsyth NP . SENT While IN his PP$ 1980 CD s NN deep JJ cover NN performance NN as IN a DT mobbed VVN up RP , , public JJ of IN cial NNS bribing VVG owner NN of IN a DT Newark NP , , New NP Jersey NP , , towing VVG company NN is VBZ fondly RB remembered VVN by IN some DT , , most JJS of IN Cloonan NP s PP FBI NP years NNS were VBD spent VVN working VVG counterintelligence NN and CC , , later RBR , , counterterrorism NN , , on IN the DT multiagency NN Joint NP Terrorism NN Task NP Force NP . SENT In IN addition NN to TO running VVG FBI NP operations NNS directed VVD at IN the DT Taliban NP s PP quasi NP of IN cial JJ New NP York NP mission NN in IN the DT late JJ 90 CD s PP , , Cloonan NP was VBD on IN the DT New NP York NP eld NN of IN ce JJS s PP Osama NP bin NN Laden JJ squad NN from IN its PP$ beginnings NNS in IN 1996 CD . SENT The DT unit NN successfully RB apprehended VVN and CC brought VVN to TO trial NN the DT al NP Qaeda NP members NNS responsible JJ for IN the DT 1998 CD U NP . SENT S NP . SENT Embassy NP bombings NNS in IN Kenya NP and CC Tanzania NP . SENT Echoing VVG the DT sentiments NNS of IN other JJ serious JJ students NNS of IN al NP Qaeda NP , , Peter NP Bergen NP , , a DT Brookings NP Institution NP fellow NN and CC a DT CNN NP terrorism NN analyst NN , , told VVD me PP that IN the DT bulk NN of IN the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT government NN s VVZ best JJS pre NP 9 CD 11 CD al NP Qaeda NP intelligence NN came VVD out RP of IN that DT investigation NN an DT endeavor NN in IN which WDT the DT interviews NNS of IN suspects NNS , , Cloonan NP gently RB but CC pointedly RB told VVD me PP , , hewed VVD strictly RB to TO FBI NP procedures NNS that WDT make VVP no DT allowances NNS for IN violence NN . SENT Based VVN on IN his PP$ experiences NNS interviewing VVG Islamist NN radicals NNS everywhere RB from IN New NP York NP City NP to TO Khartoum NP , , Cloonan NP believes VVZ that IN interrogations NNS can MD gather VV intelligence NN that IN s PP both CC operationally RB actionable JJ and CC court NN admissible JJ nothing NN that IN shocks NNS the DT conscience NN of IN the DT court NN , , as IN he PP puts VVZ it PP , , and CC holds VVZ that RB torture VV by IN hands NNS American JJ or CC foreign JJ is VBZ rarely RB ever RB useful JJ or CC necessary JJ . SENT Cloonan NP and CC a DT New NP York NP Police NP Department NP detective NN secured VVD actionable JJ intelligence NN from IN a DT suspect NN in IN the DT foiled JJ millennium NN bombing NN plot NN in IN just RB six CD hours NNS on IN December NP 30 CD , , 1999 CD by IN following VVG FBI NP procedure NN , , and CC by IN encouraging VVG a DT suspect NN to TO pray VV during IN his PP$ Ramadan NN fast RB . SENT The DT suspect NN even RB agreed VVD to TO place VV calls NNS to TO his PP$ confederates NNS , , which WDT led VVD to TO their PP$ speedy JJ arrests NNS . SENT As IN such JJ , , Cloonan NP is VBZ extremely RB unhappy JJ with IN the DT post NN 9 CD 11 CD article NN of IN faith NN that IN all DT manner NN of IN extraordinary JJ mechanisms NNS , , from IN rendition NN to TO torture VV , , are VBP somehow RB both DT necessary JJ and CC devoid JJ of IN negative JJ consequences NNS . SENT He PP took VVD serious JJ issue NN with IN the DT notion NN that IN violent JJ coercion NN is VBZ the DT only RB means VVZ of IN getting VVG Islamist NN terrorism NN suspects VVZ to TO talk VV . SENT When WRB I PP asked VVD him PP to TO elaborate VV , , he PP told VVD the DT story NN of IN Joe NP the DT Moroccan NN or CC , , more RBR formally RB , , L NP Houssaine NP Kherchtou NP , , a DT member NN of IN the DT al NP Qaeda NP cell NN that WDT bombed VVD the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT Embassy NP in IN Nairobi NP and CC the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT government NN s PP star VV witness NN in IN the DT embassy NN bombings NNS case NN . SENT Kherchtou NP rst NNS popped VVD up RP on IN Cloonan NP s PP radar NN when WRB , , in IN the DT course NN of IN his PP$ embassy NN bombings NNS investigations NNS , , Cloonan NP learned VVD that IN Kherchtou NP had VHD own JJ for IN al NP Qaeda NP and CC had VHD even RB been VBN tapped VVN to TO be VB bin NN Laden JJ s PP personal JJ pilot NN . SENT Despite IN the DT fact NN that IN Kherchtou NP became VVD the DT prosecution NN s PP star VV witness NN in IN the DT embassy NN bombings NNS trial NN , , he PP received VVD only RB passing VVG mention NN in IN a DT smattering NN of IN news NN accounts NNS , , none NN of IN which WDT ever RB actually RB explained VVD how WRB he PP came VVD to TO take VV the DT stand NN for IN and CC , , in IN the DT process NN , , provide VV a DT massive JJ amount NN of IN intelligence NN to TO the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT government NN . SENT As IN two CD glasses NNS of IN wine NN arrived VVD , , Cloonan NP began VVD to TO lay VV out RP Kherchtou NP s PP untold JJ story NN . SENT Contrary JJ to TO views NNS in IN some DT circles NNS that IN every DT al NP Qaeda NP member NN or CC radical JJ Islamist NN is VBZ so RB beset VVN by IN zealotry NN as RB to TO be VB beyond IN appeals NNS to TO reason NN or CC humanity NN , , Cloonan NP , , in IN the DT course NN of IN his PP$ investigation NN , , concluded VVD that DT Kherchtou NP whose WP$ Kenyan JJ apartment NN was VBD used VVN to TO develop VV the DT lm NN the DT Nairobi NP cell NN shot VVD in IN preparation NN for IN the DT embassy NN bombing NN there RB cared VVD at IN least JJS as RB much RB about IN his PP$ family NN as IN he PP did VVD the DT cause NN of IN Wahabbist NP jihad NN . SENT It PP was VBD , , in IN fact NN , , on IN this DT basis NN that IN MI NN 6 CD , , the DT British JJ intelligence NN service NN , , nearly RB succeeded VVN in IN recruiting VVG Kherchtou NP as IN an DT agent NN . SENT Shuttling VVG between IN Khartoum NP and CC Nairobi NP in IN the DT early JJ to TO mid JJ 90 CD s PP for IN bin NN Laden JJ who WP , , it PP critically RB turned VVD out RP later RBR for IN all DT parties NNS , , was VBD a DT miserly JJ employer NN , , Kherchtou NP returned VVD to TO Khartoum NP in IN 1995 CD and CC came VVD home NN to TO discover VV his PP$ pregnant JJ wife NN in IN need NN of IN a DT cesarean JJ section NN and CC begging VVG in IN the DT streets NNS to TO get VV money NN for IN the DT procedure NN . SENT When WRB his PP$ Muslim JJ brothers NNS in IN al NP Qaeda NP refused VVD Kherchtou NP s PP request VVP for IN 500 CD , , he PP quickly RB became VVD disillusioned VVN , , moving VVG his PP$ family NN to TO Morocco NP . SENT Though IN still RB ying NP between IN Khartoum NP and CC Nairobi NP , , he PP began VVD to TO drift VV away RB from IN al NP Qaeda NP . SENT Kherchtou NP s PP actions NNS did VVD not RB go VV unnoticed JJ by IN Morocco NP s PP intelligence NN service NN , , which WDT in IN turn NN approached VVD the DT British JJ about IN trying VVG to TO jointly RB recruit VV the DT pilot NN and CC run VV him PP as IN an DT asset NN . SENT Their PP$ rst JJS tentative JJ meeting NN took VVD place NN in IN mid JJ summer NN 1998 CD . SENT Kherchtou NP returned VVD to TO Kenya NP early JJ that IN August NP . SENT though IN no DT longer RBR active JJ in IN the DT cell NN , , he PP began VVD to TO make VV contact NN with IN his PP$ erstwhile JJ friends NNS . SENT He PP wasn NN t NN aware JJ of IN the DT actual JJ bombing NN plans NNS , , but CC when WRB the DT Nairobi NP bomb NN went VVD off RP , , Kherchtou NP had VHD a DT good JJ idea NN who WP was VBD behind IN it PP , , and CC concluded VVD that IN this DT would MD be VB a DT good JJ time NN to TO leave VV Kenya NP along RP with IN the DT shady JJ world NN of IN terrorism NN and CC espionage NN for IN good JJ . SENT Anticipating VVG his PP$ moves NNS , , the DT British NP had VHD Kenyan NN of IN cials NNS detain VV Kherchtou NP at IN the DT airport NN until IN they PP could MD arrive VV and CC spirit NN him PP to TO an DT MI NN 6 CD Nairobi NP safe JJ house NN . SENT Afterward RB he PP was VBD released VVN and CC told VVN to TO go VV back RB to TO Khartoum NP , , where WRB he PP was VBD given VVN a DT set NN of IN instructions NNS as IN to TO how WRB to TO contact VV his PP$ MI NN 6 CD handler NN . SENT Perhaps RB not RB surprisingly RB , , he PP never RB called VVD . SENT Cloonan NP remains VVZ skeptical JJ of IN British JJ claims NNS that IN MI NN 6 CD shared VVD this DT information NN with IN the DT CIA NP the DT information NN found VVD its PP$ way NN to TO him PP , , he PP said VVD , , through IN a DT back JJ channel NN he PP preferred VVD not RB to TO elaborate VV on RP . SENT But CC when WRB he PP did VVD nd NN out RP , , he PP was VBD , , to TO put VV it PP mildly RB , , unhappy JJ . SENT Go VV back RB to TO 1998 CD , , when WRB we PP ve RB got VVD hundreds NNS of IN agents NNS on IN the DT ground NN in IN Kenya NP and CC Tanzania NP trying VVG to TO gure NP out IN what WP happened VVD , , he PP says VVZ . SENT Let VV me PP just RB say VVP it PP would MD have VH been VBN real RB helpful JJ if IN the DT British NP had VHD told VVN us PP they PP had VHD one CD of IN the DT cell NN members NNS in IN custody NN . SENT After IN a DT lengthy JJ and CC often RB unpleasant JJ series NN of IN interactions NNS involving VVG CIA NP of IN cers NNS , , MI NN 6 CD of IN cers NNS , , British JJ and CC American JJ prosecutors NNS , , and CC FBI NP of IN cials NNS including VVG Cloonan NP and CC his PP$ partner NN , , Dan NP Coleman NP , , the DT British NP eventually RB shared VVD the DT transcripts NNS of IN Kherchtou NP s PP safe JJ house NN interviews NNS and CC agreed VVD to TO consider VV him PP no RB longer RBR under IN development NN as IN a DT potential JJ asset NN thus RB leaving VVG him PP to TO the DT mercies NNS of IN prosecution NN minded VVD Americans NNS . SENT Though IN the DT British JJ and CC Moroccan JJ secret JJ services NNS were VBD not RB referred VVN to TO by IN name NN during IN the DT embassy NN bombings NNS trial NN , , then RB Assistant NP U NP . SENT S NP . SENT Attorney NP Patrick NP Fitzgerald NP did VVD ask VV Kherchtou NP in IN open JJ court NN about IN his PP$ interaction NN including VVG his PP$ attempted JJ recruitment NN and CC safe JJ house NN time NN with IN unnamed JJ foreign JJ intelligence NN services NNS . SENT While IN The DT New NP York NP Times NP dutifully RB reported VVD this DT part NN of IN Kherchtou NP s PP testimony NN in IN two CD sentences NNS toward IN the DT end NN of IN a DT short JJ story NN on IN page NN B NP 3 CD of IN the DT paper NN s PP February NP 23 CD , , 2001 CD , , edition NN , , neither CC the DT Times NPS nor CC any DT other JJ media NN organization NN covering VVG the DT trial NN made VVD any DT attempt NN to TO discern VV which WDT intelligence NN services NNS Kherchtou NP had VHD interacted VVN with IN , , or CC why WRB they PP had VHD not RB shared VVN Kherchtou NP s PP identity NN with IN the DT United NP States NPS . SENT He PP is VBZ now RB in IN witness NN protection NN . SENT But CC Cloonan NP needed VVD to TO get VV Kherchtou NP back RB to TO Morocco NP . SENT Rather RB than IN have VHP an DT intelligence NN service NN kidnap VV him PP , , Cloonan NP asked VVD the DT Moroccans NNS to TO inform VV Kherchtou NP that IN his PP$ children NNS s PP immigration NN status NN was VBD in IN question NN . SENT Kherchtou NP left VVD Khartoum NP for IN Rabat NP , , Morocco NP s PP capital NN , , almost RB immediately RB . SENT Upon IN his PP$ return NN to TO Morocco NP a DT country NN whose WP$ security NN services NNS routinely RB engage VVP in RB torture VV , , according VVG to TO the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT State NP Department NP , , Amnesty NN International NP , , and CC others NNS Kherchtou NP was VBD , , at IN the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT government NN s PP request VVP , , taken VVN into IN custody NN and CC immediately RB brought VVN to TO a DT Rabat NP safe JJ house NN , , where WRB an DT array NN of IN FBI NP agents NNS including VVG Cloonan NP , , and CC assistant JJ U NP . SENT S NP . SENT attorneys NNS led VVN by IN Patrick NP Fitzgerald NP , , were VBD waiting VVG . SENT The DT coming JJ days NNS , , Cloonan NP said VVD , , were VBD probably RB the DT most RBS comfortable JJ either CC he PP or CC Kherchtou NP has VHZ ever RB spent VVN , , utterly RB antithetical JJ to TO tales NNS from IN Abu NP Ghraib NP , , Bagram NP Air NP Base NP in IN Afghanistan NP , , and CC elsewhere RB involving VVG shackles NNS , , beatings NNS , , weatherboardings NNS , , genital JJ electric JJ shocks NNS , , and CC menstrual JJ smearing VVG that DT have VHP become VVN ubiquitous JJ in IN the DT past JJ year NN . SENT The DT setting NN was VBD beautiful JJ , , Cloonan NP recalled VVD . SENT It PP was VBD this DT grand JJ house NN with IN stables NNS out IN back RB , , gazelles NNS bouncing VVG in IN the DT background NN , , palm NN trees NNS , , three CD course NN meals NNS I PP was VBD probably RB more JJR in IN danger NN of IN getting VVG gout NN from IN all PDT the DT rich JJ food NN than IN anything NN else RB while IN I PP was VBD there RB . SENT We PP advised VVD Kherchtou NP of IN his PP$ rights NNS . SENT We PP told VVD him PP he PP could MD have VH a DT lawyer NN anytime RB , , and CC that IN he PP could MD pray VV at IN any DT time NN he PP wanted VVD . SENT We PP were VBD letting VVG the DT Moroccans NNS sit VVP in IN on IN this DT , , and CC they PP were VBD dumbfounded JJ . SENT The DT agents NNS and CC prosecutors NNS did VVD not RB anticipate VV ease VV in IN the DT task NN before IN them PP . SENT Simply RB getting VVG information NN out RP of IN a DT person NN can MD be VB a DT formidable JJ challenge NN . SENT persuading VVG him PP or CC her PP$ to TO not RB only RB give VV up RP information NN but CC to TO go VV through IN a DT lengthy JJ process NN in IN which WDT he PP or CC she PP will MD repeat VV it PP again RB and CC again RB including VVG in IN an DT open JJ American JJ court NN , , with IN no DT assurance NN of IN plea NN bargain NN is VBZ even RB more RBR daunting JJ . SENT But CC 10 CD days NNS later RBR , , Kherchtou NP had VHD not RB only RB revealed VVN much RB but CC was VBD New NP York NP bound VVN , , destined VVN to TO become VV the DT prosecution NN s PP star VV witness NN in IN securing VVG the DT convictions NNS of IN four CD al NP Qaeda NP terrorists NNS . SENT We PP spent VVD a DT lot NN of IN time NN talking VVG about IN his PP$ family NN , , and CC how WRB disillusioned VVD he PP was VBD based VVN on IN the DT brothers NNS treatment NN of IN them PP , , and CC from IN there EX he PP really RB began VVD to TO open VV up RP , , Cloonan NP recalled VVD . SENT The DT critical JJ moment NN was VBD when WRB Pat NP Fitzgerald NP told VVD Joe NP , , Here RB s PP the DT deal NN . SENT You PP will MD come VV to TO the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT voluntarily RB . SENT you PP will MD plead VV guilty JJ to TO conspiracy NN to TO kill VV U NP . SENT S NP . SENT nationals NNS abroad RB . SENT your PP$ exposure NN is VBZ anywhere RB from IN zero CD to TO life NN , , no DT promises NNS . SENT I PP instinctively RB reached VVD for IN my PP$ briefcase NN , , guring VVG it PP was VBD over RP , , but CC then RB I PP added VVD something NN . SENT I PP looked VVD at IN him PP and CC I PP said VVD , , Before IN you PP answer VVP , , I PP think VVP you PP should MD go VV pray VV . SENT After IN 10 CD days NNS with IN us PP , , I PP think VVP you PP have VHP a DT sense NN of IN who WP we PP are VBP and CC what WP we PP re IN about IN you PP know VVP you PP would MD not RB be VB treated VVN this DT way NN by IN other JJ folks NNS . SENT You PP may MD go VV to TO prison NN , , but CC you PP have VHP the DT chance NN to TO start VV your PP$ life NN over IN again RB , , to TO get VV rid JJ of IN this DT anxiety NN , , to TO stop VV running VVG . SENT And CC I PP think VVP you PP should MD do VV this DT for IN your PP$ wife NN and CC children NNS . SENT So RB he PP went VVD off RP to TO pray VV . SENT Meanwhile RB , , the DT colonel NN from IN the DT Moroccan JJ internal JJ service NN just RB looked VVD at IN us PP like VVP we PP were VBD from IN Mars NP . SENT But CC Joe NP came VVD back RB and CC said VVD , , OK UH . SENT Such JJ , , Cloonan NP later RBR told VVD me PP , , was VBD the DT beginning NN of IN a DT happy JJ ending NN . SENT Kherchtou NP was VBD brought VVN to TO New NP York NP . SENT anything NN in IN further JJR interviews NNS or CC proffer NN sessions NNS deemed VVN of IN immediate JJ importance NN was VBD shared VVN with IN the DT CIA NP . SENT four CD terrorists NNS were VBD convicted VVN . SENT a DT detailed JJ public JJ record NN providing VVG detailed JJ insight NN into IN al NP Qaeda NP including VVG the DT group NN s PP interest NN in IN using VVG suicide NN piloted VVD planes NNS as IN bombers NNS was VBD produced VVN . SENT By IN contrast NN , , Cloonan NP says VVZ , , there EX was VBD the DT case NN of IN Ibn NP al NP Shaykh NP al NP Libi NP , , a DT case NN he PP thinks VVZ adequately RB illustrates VVZ how WRB uninformed JJ and CC counterproductive JJ notions NNS have VHP come VVN to TO dominate VV the DT post NN 9 CD 11 CD environment NN . SENT The DT story NN had VHD only RB a DT happy JJ beginning NN . SENT At IN rst NN , , Cloonan NP says VVZ , , Army NP debriefers NNS at IN Bagram NP were VBD enthusiastically RB deferential JJ to TO FBI NP personnel NNS . SENT Though IN FBI NP agents NNS were VBD technically RB subordinate JJ to TO the DT Army NP chain NN of IN command NN , , many JJ of IN the DT military JJ intelligence NN interrogators NNS were VBD keenly RB aware JJ of IN how WRB little JJ they PP know VVP about IN counterterrorism NN in IN general NN and CC all DT things NNS Islamic JJ in IN particular JJ . SENT The DT general NN in IN charge NN of IN the DT base NN loved VVD our PP$ guys NNS he PP actually RB asked VVD them PP to TO start VV training VVG the DT military JJ intelligence NN guys NNS on IN how WRB to TO do VV proper JJ debrie NN ngs NNS , , and CC it PP went VVD really RB well RB , , Cloonan NP recalled VVD with IN a DT touch NN of IN pride NN . SENT He PP even RB called VVD the DT director NN personally RB to TO say VV thank VV you PP for IN these DT guys NNS and CC what WP they PP did VVD . SENT Among IN the DT military JJ s NN captives NNS in IN December NP 2001 CD was VBD al NP Libi NP , , who WP disclosed VVD early RB on IN that WDT he PP had VHD been VBN the DT emir NN of IN the DT training NN camp NN that WDT had VHD produced VVN both DT Richard NP Reid NP and CC Zacarias NP Moussaoui NP . SENT Fully RB appreciative JJ of IN al NP Libi NP s PP import VVP as RB both CC a DT window NN into IN understanding VVG al NP Qaeda NP s VVZ 9 CD 11 CD operations NNS and CC as IN a DT potential JJ witness NN in IN the DT Moussaoui NP case NN , , the DT FBI NP agent NN and CC NYPD JJ detective NN assigned VVN to TO al NP Libi NP called VVD their PP$ mentor NN , , Cloonan NP , , in IN New NP York NP as IN they PP waited VVD to TO interview VV him PP . SENT Says VVZ Cloonan NP . SENT I PP told VVD them PP , , When WRB you PP get VVP access NN , , don VV t NN say VVP anything NN at IN rst NNS . SENT Sit VV . SENT say VV hello NN after IN awhile RB . SENT offer VV him PP tea NN , , dates NNS , , gs NNS . SENT Point NN out IN where WRB Mecca NP is VBZ . SENT ask VV him PP if IN he PP wants VVZ to TO pray VV . SENT And CC sit VV . SENT And CC when WRB he PP starts VVZ to TO look VV a DT little RB inquisitive JJ , , tell VV him PP who WP you PP are VBP , , and CC that IN he PP has VHZ rights NNS and CC privileges NNS , , and CC that IN you PP re IN going VVG to TO give VV him PP his PP$ rights NNS . SENT Just RB like IN any DT other JJ interview NN . SENT So RB they PP do VVP all PDT this DT . SENT And CC they PP start VVP building NN rapport NN . SENT And CC he PP starts VVZ talking VVG about IN Reid NP and CC Moussaoui NP . SENT They PP re IN getting VVG good JJ stuff NN , , and CC everyone NN s PP getting VVG the DT raw JJ 302 CD s PP interview NN summaries NNS the DT agency NN , , the DT military NN , , the DT director NN . SENT But CC for IN some DT reason NN , , the DT CIA NP chief NN of IN station NN in IN Kabul NP is VBZ taking VVG issue NN with IN our PP$ approach NN . SENT In IN Cloonan NP s PP view VVP , , what WP happened VVD next IN was VBD a DT result NN of IN the DT politics NNS of IN post NN 9 CD 11 CD , , both CC generally RB and CC within IN the DT national JJ security NN community NN . SENT While IN 9 CD 11 CD had VHD not RB been VBN a DT proud JJ day NN for IN the DT CIA NP , , at IN least JJS the DT same JJ , , if IN not RB more RBR so RB , , was VBD true JJ for IN the DT FBI NP . SENT Unlike IN the DT CIA NP director NN , , the DT FBI NP director NN lacks VVZ cabinet NN rank NN . SENT And CC , , unlike IN the DT CIA NP director NN , , whose WP$ comments NNS about IN getting VVG boots NNS on IN the DT ground NN and CC taking VVG the DT gloves NNS off RP both CC appealed VVD to TO the DT president NN s PP sensibilities NNS and CC could MD be VB quickly RB actualized VVN by IN virtue NN of IN the DT CIA NP s PP black JJ budget NN , , the DT FBI NP director NN had VHD no DT such JJ budget NN nor CC any DT real JJ desire NN to TO enable VV practices NNS of IN dubious JJ ef NN cacy NP . SENT A DT series NN of IN conference NN calls NNS ensued VVD among IN military NN , , CIA NP , , and CC FBI NP of IN cials NNS . SENT in IN the DT end NN , , over IN both CC the DT military JJ and CC Mueller NP s PP objections NNS , , the DT CIA NP s NN prerogative NN carried VVD the DT day NN which WDT meant VVD al NP Libi NP would MD be VB rendered VVN to TO Cairo NP for IN interrogation NN by IN Egypt NP s PP intelligence NN service NN this DT was VBD discussed VVN by IN Jane NP Mayer NP in IN her PP$ article NN on IN renditions NNS in IN The DT New NP Yorker NP this DT past JJ February NP . SENT What WP Cloonan NP s PP agents NNS told VVD him PP happened VVD next JJ blew VVD his PP$ mind NN . SENT My PP$ guys NNS told VVD me PP that IN a DT Toyota NP Tundra NN with IN a DT box NN in IN the DT back NN pulls VVZ up RP to TO the DT building NN , , he PP recalls VVZ . SENT CIA NP of IN cers NNS come VVN in IN , , start VV shackling VVG al NP Libi NP up RB . SENT Right RB before IN they PP duct NN tape VVP his PP$ mouth NN , , he PP tells VVZ our PP$ guys NNS , , I PP know VVP this DT isn NN t NN your PP$ fault NN . SENT And CC as IN he PP s PP standing VVG there RB , , chained VVN and CC gagged VVN , , this DT CIA NP guy NN gets VVZ up RP in IN his PP$ face NN and CC tells VVZ al NP Libi NP he PP s VVZ going VVG to TO fuck VV his PP$ mother NN . SENT And CC then RB off IN he PP apparently RB goes VVZ to TO Cairo NP , , in IN a DT box NN . SENT Cloonan NP says VVZ CIA NP of IN cials VVZ he PP later RBR spoke VVD with IN furiously RB denied VVN al NP Libi NP was VBD actually RB put VVN in IN the DT box NN . SENT But CC he PP seems VVZ to TO consider VV this DT at IN best JJS a DT matter NN of IN hairsplitting NN , , as IN there EX was VBD no DT question NN as IN to TO what WP kind NN of IN situation NN al NP Libi NP was VBD being VBG delivered VVN to TO in IN Egypt NP . SENT Which WDT brings VVZ us PP to TO renditions NNS . SENT The DT rst NN time NN Cloonan NP had VHD heard VVN of IN renditions NNS was VBD 1998 CD , , when WRB Albanian JJ and CC CIA NP of IN cials NNS broke VVD up RP an DT al NP Qaeda NP cell NN in IN Tirana NP . SENT Cloonan NP s PP CIA NP counterparts NNS said VVD they PP would MD be VB happy JJ to TO see VV that DT anything NN of IN utility NN found VVD its PP$ way NN to TO the DT bureau NN , , but CC neither DT Cloonan NP nor CC his PP$ colleagues NNS were VBD particularly RB comfortable JJ with IN the DT CIA NP s PP description NN of IN how WRB that DT process NN was VBD going VVG to TO work VV . SENT When WRB we PP were VBD told VVN that IN the DT way NN this DT was VBD going VVG to TO go NN was VBD , , a DT plane NN ies NN in IN from IN Egypt NP and CC these DT guys NNS get VVP put VVN on IN a DT plane NN with IN a DT one CD way NN ticket NN to TO the DT Egyptian NP GIS NP , , we PP weren NNS t NN thrilled VVN on IN a DT number NN of IN levels NNS , , he PP recalled VVD . SENT The DT agency NN people NNS were VBD , , to TO their PP$ credit NN , , very RB adamant JJ that IN they PP didn NN t NN want VVP people NNS tortured JJ . SENT But CC I PP never RB quite RB understood VVN how WRB any DT agency NN of IN cer NNS , , however RB diligent JJ they PP might MD be VB , , could MD be VB with IN someone NN 24 CD hours NNS a DT day NN to TO make VV sure JJ that IN they PP weren NN t NN tortured VVN . SENT Not RB long RB after IN the DT al NP Libi NP rendering NN , , Mueller NP paid VVD a DT visit NN to TO the DT Counterterrorism NN Division NN in IN the DT New NP York NP eld NN of IN ce NNS . SENT In IN a DT question NN and CC answer NN session NN in IN the DT auditorium NN adjacent JJ to TO the DT counterterrorism NN of IN ces NN , , Cloonan NP raised VVD his PP$ hand NN . SENT Have VHP you PP had VHD the DT opportunity NN to TO give VV some DT thought NN as IN to TO what WP you PP would MD advise VV agents NNS to TO do VV if IN they PP nd NN themselves PP in IN the DT following VVG position NN . SENT Cloonan NP says VVZ he PP asked VVD . SENT You PP have VHP a DT subject NN being VBG interviewed VVN who WP has VHZ been VBN advised VVN of IN his PP$ rights NNS , , is VBZ not RB a DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT citizen NN , , and CC is VBZ outside IN the DT U NP . SENT S PP . SENT , , but CC that DT person NN has VHZ agreed VVN to TO cooperate VV , , but CC that DT person NN is VBZ being VBG forcibly RB removed VVN from IN your PP$ custody NN and CC rendered VVN to TO a DT third JJ country NN where WRB his PP$ due JJ process NN is VBZ being VBG denied VVN . SENT I PP wasn NN t NN that WDT far RB from IN him PP I PP could MD see VV on IN his PP$ face NN how WRB this DT pained JJ him PP , , because IN this DT was VBD only RB a DT short JJ while NN after IN the DT al NP Libi NP rendering NN . SENT But CC the DT director NN basically RB blew VVD me PP off RP . SENT He PP had VHD no DT advice NN . SENT His PP$ response NN was VBD , , Well UH , , I PP m NN not RB sure RB it PP s VVZ an DT issue NN , , as IN it PP s PP a DT non JJ U NP . SENT S NP . SENT citizen NN outside IN the DT U NP . SENT S NP . SENT At IN that DT point NN , , Cloonan NP began VVD to TO see VV a DT truly RB bleak JJ long JJ term NN future NN . SENT At IN the DT end NN of IN the DT day NN , , he PP says VVZ , , you PP have VHP to TO ask VV . SENT Was VBD it PP worth JJ it PP . SENT It PP s PP no RB more RBR complicated JJ than IN that DT . SENT Pictures NNS have VHP been VBN broadcast VVN all RB over IN the DT world NN . SENT eventually RB the DT stuff NN all DT leaks NNS out RP . SENT Have VHP we PP gotten VVN enough JJ information NN out IN of IN Guantanamo NP Bay NP or CC anywhere RB else RB to TO justify VV the DT negative JJ . SENT I PP think VVP the DT answer NN from IN the DT authorities NNS will MD be VB , , We PP ve VVZ gotten VVN great JJ information NN . SENT I PP m NN less RBR and CC less RBR inclined JJ to TO believe VV that IN . SENT There EX s PP a DT certain JJ na TO vet NN in IN thinking VVG that IN any DT schmuck NN taken VVN off IN the DT battle NN eld NN on IN any DT given VVN day NN or CC taken VVN of IN a DT street NN somewhere RB and CC own VV halfway RB around IN the DT world NN and CC being VBG held VVN incommunicado RB with IN no DT rights NNS and CC no DT charges NNS will MD know VV where WRB bin NN Laden JJ is VBZ or CC what WP s PP going VVG to TO be VB planned VVN in IN Iraq NP or CC Afghanistan NP . SENT And CC when WRB those DT people NNS start VVP to TO get VV repatriated VVN and CC go VV back RB , , what WP are VBP they PP going VVG to TO tell VV people NNS about IN America NP . SENT That IN it PP was VBD a DT great JJ three CD or CC four CD years NNS in IN a DT stockade NN or CC in IN some DT other JJ security NN services NNS cell NN . SENT Maybe RB one CD or CC two CD people NNS will MD say VV we PP re IN a DT great JJ country NN . SENT But CC we PP ve VVZ probably RB created VVN 450 CD new JJ terrorists NNS . SENT Jason NP Vest NP is VBZ a DT Prospect NP senior JJ correspondent NN . SENT 2005 CD by IN The DT American NP Prospect NP , , Inc NP . SENT Meet VV Our PP$ Writers NP Special JJ Reports NPS Immigration NN Reform NP The NP Environment NP . SENT Death NN and CC Rebirth NN Juvenile JJ Justice NP All DT Special JJ Reports NNS Moving VVG Ideas NNS American JJ Education NP Week NP . SENT Nov NP 13 CD 19 CD . SENT In IN honor NN of IN this DT celebration NN of IN public JJ schools NNS , , these DT resources NNS focus VVP on IN the DT challenges NNS schools NNS face VVP , , reforms NNS and CC innovative JJ strategies NNS to TO fix VV them PP , , and CC tools NNS for IN advocates NNS and CC parents NNS . SENT Progressive JJ E NN Newsletters NNS and CC RSS NP Feeds VVZ . SENT 22 CD issues NNS and CC content NN from IN more JJR than IN 180 CD organizations NNS . SENT Policy NN reports NNS , , action NN alerts VVZ , , articles NNS , , and CC more JJR . SENT The DT Moving VVG Ideas NNS Network NP is VBZ a DT project NN of IN The DT American NP Prospect NP About IN Us NP Daily NP Prospect NP Current JJ Issue NN Tapped VVD Archives NPS Advertise VVP Subscribe VV Donate NP Home NP 2005 CD The DT American JJ Prospect NP http NN . SENT www JJ . SENT prospect NN . SENT org NP